Why Inquiring About Newcomer Canadian Work Experience Raises Questions of Legality?

In today’s competitive job market, newcomers to Canada often face questions regarding their Canadian work experience. Employers may inquire about this aspect during interviews, leading to confusion and concerns among job seekers. Within this blog, we shall delve into the legality and ramifications surrounding the inquiries posed by employers regarding newcomers’ Canadian work experience.

Overcoming Newcomer Job Barriers in Canada

Newcomers often face challenges securing meaningful work in Canada due to a lack of Canadian experience. The Ontario Human Rights Commission identifies barriers, including unrecognized foreign credentials, language difficulties, and over-qualification rejection. The Canadian Human Rights Act deems federal-sector age, gender, and other inquiries illegal. While provincial laws govern most employers, they align with federal principles.

Addressing the Question: Is It Illegal?

One common concern among newcomers is whether it is legal for employers to inquire about their lack of Canadian work experience. It’s important to note that Canadian labor laws prohibit discrimination based on various factors, including national origin and race. While asking about Canadian work experience may not be explicitly illegal, it could potentially be considered discriminatory if used as the sole criterion for hiring decisions.

According to the Human rights tribunals, “Canadian experience” queries may be discriminatory unless they are relevant to the job. Any employer demanding Canadian work experience could lead to discrimination based on factors like race, ancestry, and origin.

The Ontario Human Rights Commission’s guide, “Removing the ‘Canadian Experience’ Barrier,” emphasizes legitimate job requirements, offering best practices to ensure inclusivity and compliance with the Ontario Human Rights Code.

The Role of Canadian Experience

Employers may inquire about Canadian work experience for various reasons. They might believe that individuals with local experience will adapt more quickly to the work environment. However, it’s essential to recognize that the Canadian experience is not the only indicator of an individual’s ability to succeed in a role.

What Employers are Allowed to Ask?

Employers can question your qualifications and job-related abilities. They may inquire about criminal records and request police checks. While Canadian work experience queries are prohibited, the legality to work in Canada can be discussed.

Across Canada, workers, including foreigners, are safeguarded by federal and provincial labor laws. Fair treatment and discrimination-free workplaces are ensured under the Canadian Human Rights Act, encompassing gender, race, ethnicity, and more. These protections extend to permanent residents and individuals with work or study visas.

Encouraging Inclusive Hiring Practices

In the domain of employment, employers play a pivotal role in nurturing diversity and inclusivity. Beyond focusing solely on Canadian work experience, employers should consider international exposure, education, and relevant skills. Embracing inclusive recruitment practices enables employers to tap into diverse talent pools, fostering dynamic and vibrant environments.

Austin Campbell

Austin has been quite active in the immigration arena since 2010. He has authored over 250 immigration publications, given over 70 presentations, and organized numerous events featuring federal and provincial immigration ministers and leaders from other sectors. He is a graduate of the University of Toronto and Durham University.
View Profile View All Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.